Why Folic Acid Isn’t Cutting It—And What to Do Instead

Written By Grace Parce

If you’ve been told to take folic acid before getting pregnant, you’re not alone—it’s one of the most widely recommended nutrients for women in their reproductive years.

But here’s the thing: folic acid ≠ folate, and for many women (especially those with MTHFR gene variants), that difference matters a lot.

In fact, synthetic folic acid might be doing you more harm than good.

Let’s break it down—what the science says, how this might be affecting your body, and what you can actually do to protect your fertility, mood, and hormone health.

What Is Folic Acid—And Why It Can Be a Problem

Folic acid is the synthetic form of vitamin B9, commonly added to supplements and fortified foods like cereal, bread, and energy bars. It was introduced during the 1990s to reduce the risk of neural tube defects in babies—and it worked. Neural tube defect rates dropped by nearly 35% after folic acid fortification was introduced in the U.S. in 1998 (CDC, 2010).

But here’s the problem: folic acid is not biologically active. It needs to be converted through a multi-step process into 5-MTHF (methylfolate)—the form your body actually uses.

For women with a MTHFR gene variant (which up to 60% of the population carries in some form), that conversion is sluggish or inefficient. According to Dr. Ben Lynch, women with a C677T heterozygous mutation may have 30–40% reduced enzyme function. For those who are homozygous, that number may be closer to 60–70%.

And what happens when your body can’t process synthetic folic acid efficiently?

It builds up unmetabolized folic acid in your bloodstream—which has been linked to:

  • Increased inflammation

  • Lower natural killer (NK) cell activity

  • Impaired detox pathways

  • Hormonal imbalances

  • Anxiety and mood swings

Lily Nichols, RDN and author of Real Food for Pregnancy, cautions that synthetic folic acid may block folate receptors, making it harder for your body to absorb natural folate from food—especially problematic when your body is trying to conceive or detox excess estrogen.

Signs You May Not Be Processing Folic Acid Well

If you’re dealing with any of these, it’s time to take a closer look at how your body is handling folate:

  • You feel tired or foggy even with plenty of rest

  • PMS hits hard: anxiety, bloating, mood swings, breast tenderness

  • You’ve had early pregnancy losses or fertility struggles

  • You get headaches, histamine flares, or skin breakouts before your period

  • You’ve had postpartum mood issues or poor detox symptoms (e.g. can’t tolerate alcohol, strong smells, meds)

These symptoms don’t always scream “folate problem,” but when paired with MTHFR mutations, they’re often rooted in methylation issues—your body’s ability to detox, balance hormones, and recycle key neurotransmitters like serotonin and dopamine.

Where Folic Acid Hides (Hint: It’s Not Just in Your Vitamins)

Most people assume folic acid is just something you find in prenatals—but it’s everywhere in the modern food system:

  • White and whole wheat bread labeled “enriched”

  • Cereal, granola bars, pasta, and snack foods

  • Most over-the-counter multivitamins and prenatals (check the label!)

  • Protein powders and energy drinks with B-vitamin blends

If you're eating a lot of processed foods or taking a supplement with “folic acid” instead of “methylfolate” or “folinic acid,” you're likely overwhelming your folate pathways—even if you don’t have an MTHFR mutation.

What to Do Instead: Gentle, Supportive Folate Nourishment

You don’t need to panic or overhaul everything overnight. Here’s how to shift toward folate your body can actually use:

Choose the Right Supplement

Look for methylated folate (5-MTHF) or folinic acid, not “folic acid.”
Brands like FullWell, Seeking Health, Needed, and Thorne make excellent methyl-friendly options.

Eat Whole-Food Folate

Load your plate with:

  • Leafy greens (spinach, romaine, chard)

  • Liver (nature’s B vitamin superfood)

  • Avocado, asparagus, beets, lentils

  • Citrus, berries, and broccoli

Support Methylation (Especially if You Have MTHFR)

  • B12 (methylcobalamin) – supports mood and nerve health

  • Magnesium – cofactor for methylation enzymes

  • Choline-rich foods – like eggs, liver, and sunflower lecithin

  • Zinc + riboflavin (B2) – help convert folate properly

Eat less processed, enriched food

  • Swap “enriched wheat” for sourdough, sprouted, or cassava bread

  • Trade boxed cereals for steel-cut oats, soaked grains, or eggs + fruit

  • Focus on real food—your body knows exactly what to do with it

Final Thoughts

It’s not the end of the world if you’ve been taking folic acid or eating enriched foods. I have to remind myself this often when I make changes in my dietary habits. But once you understand how your body works—and how small tweaks like changing your supplement or switching to folate-rich foods can transform your cycle, mood, and fertility—you’re on a completely different path.

One that’s informed and empowered.

If you suspect you may have the MTHFR gene or you’re experiencing symptoms tied to poor methylation or hormonal imbalance, charting your cycle and upgrading your folate sources is one of the best places to start.

References:

Grace Parce
Previous

You Are Not a Small Man: What Every Woman Should Know About Intermittent Fasting
Next

Ceremonial Cacao & Cycle Care: A Ritual for Your Hormones